Menu

Fresh, delicious food!

When you come in to Nicky's Pizza, you will get delicious, amazing pizza and Italian classics that are always made fresh. You'll never get greasy, lukewarm food, because our whole family takes pride in giving you the best quality meal possible. 

Pizza & Calzones

Nothing beats a hot, gooey pizza for dinner. Nothing beats a Nicky's Pizza fresh, steamy pizza for dinner! You'll love our simple, delicious ingredients and extra selection of toppings.

  • Cheese

    • Small - $13.00
    • Small/Med - $16.00
    • Med/Large - $20.00
    • Large - $24.00
    • Party - $27.00
    • Calzones - $16.00
    • 12" Gluten Free & 10" Cauliflower  - $12.00
    • 14" Cauliflower - $17.00

  • Combo

    Combination- Pepperoni, Hamburger, Mushroom, Peppers

    **No Substitutions**

    • Small - $15.00
    • Small/Med - $18.00
    • Med/Large - $23.00
    • Large - $28.00
    • Party - $31.00
    • Calzones - $18.00
    • 12" Gluten Free & 10" Cauliflower  - $14.00
    • 14" Cauliflower - $19.00

  • 1 Topping

    • Small - $14.00
    • Small/Med - $17.00
    • Med/Large - $22.00
    • Large - $26.00
    • Party - $29.00
    • Calzones - $17.00
    • 12" Gluten Free & 10" Cauliflower - $13.00
    • 14" Cauliflower - $18.00

  • By The Slice

    • Cheese - 3.50
    • Combo - 4.25
    • 1 Topping - 3.75

    Or Make Your Own!

  • Vegatarian

    Vegetarian- Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions

    **No Substitutions**

    • Small - $16.00
    • Small/Med - $19.00
    • Med/Large - $24.00
    • Large - $29.00
    • Party - $33.00
    • Calzones - $19.00
    • 12" Gluten Free & 10" Cauliflower - $15.00
    • 14" Cauliflower - $20.00

  • Hawaiian

    Hawaiian- Pineapple, Ham, Bacon

    **No Substitutions**

    • Small - $16.00
    • Small/Med - $19.00
    • Med/Large - $24.00
    • Large - $29.00
    • Party - $33.00
    • Calzones - $19.00
    • 12" Gluten Free & 10" Cauliflower - $15.00
    • 14" Cauliflower - $20.00

  • Extra Toppings

    Sausage, Anchovies, Onions, Olives, Ham, Bacon, Broccoli, Pineapple, Chicken, Eggplant, or Jalapenos

    • Small - $1.25/ea
    • Small/Med - $1.50/ea
    • Med/Large - $1.75/ea
    • Large - $2.00/ea
    • Party - $2.25/ea
    • Calzones - $1.25/ea

 Grinders & Wraps

When your sandwich or wrap comes from Nicky's Pizza, you know you're getting fresh, delicious ingredients in every bite. Whatever your taste is, you can get a grinder or wrap that satisfies even your strongest cravings.

  • Bacon Cheeseburger

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Bacon Lettuce and Tomato

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Cheeseburger Special

    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Chicken Cutlet

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Chicken Parm

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Clam Strip

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Cold Cut

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Eggplant Parmesan

    Small 8" - $8.00

    Large 12" - $9.50

  • Fish Filet

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Genoa Salami

    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Ham & Cheese

    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Ham & Salami

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Hamburger Special

    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Meatball

    Small 8" - $8.00

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Mortadella

    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Pastrami

    Small 8" - $8.00

    Large 12" - $9.50

  • Philly Chicken

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Pepperoni

    Small 8" - $8.00

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Roast Beef

    Small 8" - $8.50

    Large 12" - $9.75

  • Sausage

    Small 8" - $8.00

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Steak & Cheese

    Small 8" - $8.50

    Large 12" - $9.75

  • Steak Bomb

    Steak Bomb - Steak, Onions, Peppers, Genoa Salami, Tomato


    Small 8" - $9.50

    Large 12" - $10.50

  • Tuna Fish

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Turkey

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Veal Parm

    Small 8" - $7.75

    Large 12" - $9.25

  • Vegetarian

    Vegetarian - Onions, Peppers, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato


    Small 8" - $7.50

    Large 12" - $9.00

  • Extras

    • Onions - $0.25
    • Peppers - $0.25
    • Mushroom - $0.40
    • Pickles  - $0.25
    • Olives - $0.25
    • Hot Peppers - $0.25

Appetizers & Sides

When you get appetizers from Nicky's Pizza, you're getting fresh, fragrant additions to your meal that are great to share and really get you ready for the main course.From homemade soups to freshly fried onion rings, you'll find something for everyone on our appetizer menu!

  • French Fries

    Small $4.00

    Large $5.00

  • Curly Fries

    Small $4.00

    Large $5.00

  • Tossed Salad

    Small $3.50

    Large $5.00


  • Onion Rings

    Small $4.00

    Large $5.00

  • Garlic Bread

    Small $2.50

    Large $3.00

  • Antipasto

    Small $8.00

    Large $10.00

  • Grill Chicken Salad

    Small $8.00

    Large $10.00

  • Crispy Chicken Salad

    Small $8.00

    Large $10.00

  • Fried Mozzarella

    $7.00

  • Jalapeno Poppers

    $8.00

  • Mac & Cheese Bites

    (15) $7.00

    (30) $11.00

  • Buffalo Wings

    (10) $9.50

    (15) $14.00

    (30) $26.00

  • Soups

    Soup of the Day 

Dinner Menu

You'll never go back after trying Nicky's Pizza's take on these classic, comforting dishes straight from Italian kitchens. Pasta isn't all you can get from us, you'll love our seafood dishes just as much!

All pasta dinners are served with house salad and bread.

  • Lasagna

    $13.00

  • Manicotti

    $11.00


  • Stuffed Shells

    $11.00


  • Chicken Tenders w/ Fries

    $9.00

  • Clam Strips w/ Fries

    $11.00

  • Fish N Chips

    $12.00

  • Shrimp w/ Fries

    $12.00

  • Scallops w/ Fries

    $12.00

  • Ziti or Spaghetti with

    Plain - $7.50

    Meatballs - $11.00

    Sausage - $11.00

    Veal Parm - $12.00

    Chicken Parm - $12.00

    Eggplant Parm $14.00

Have an event coming up and looking for a great place to cater?

Look no further! Nicky's pizza not only cooks for your family on busy nights, but we also cater large events with the best Italian dishes around. So if you are looking for a dependable Caterer to supply your next get together with delicious food, we have your back!

Check out our photo gallery and fill out our form with the events details and we will get back to you shortly!
Share by: